Posted by Phil Hargis on August 9th, 2010 |
2 comments
Apologies in advance for the lengthy write up….but you need to know the full deal.
Last Friday, I went to Mad Fox Brewing Company for the first time. I was so stoked to have a nice, fairly upscale version of Sweetwater Tavern dropped into downtown City of Falls Church.
When I got the menu, I wanted to order everything…..it all sounded sooooo good…but with careful restraint, I opted for the tuna tartare and bloody mary mussels, and managed to squeeze in tastes from around the table on the pizza, the chick pea curry soup of the day and the pretzels.
The tuna tartare was good and came along with a pretty generous portion of meat. It was served with 4 measly fried crisps to put it on, so make sure to ask for a few extra of those.
Then a pretty generous portion of blood mary mussels obviously came out in a tomato broth…however the celery element of these mussels demolished all the flavor of the mussel….basically leaving you soaking off the mussels of sauce to enjoy the meat. That said you had some nice pieces of bread to soak in the broth…so what you end up with is a pretty expensive dipping station and a side of mussels.
The grilled cheese was a failure and last I checked is now my lowest ranked grilled cheese on phargis.com. I opted for the addition of the Nueske bacon which I was excited to see on the menu as an option, but when they loaded up the thinly sliced bread with all that cheese and some undercooked bacon and squashed the living hell out of it you are left with a flimsy, greasy mess. The smart move of the night was substituting the brussel sprouts for the fries. The sprouts were good and tasty and seasoned pretty well. There was a pittance of a portion, presumably because of the substitution.
In bites I stole from others…the pretzels were great, but geez, how do you mess up a pretzel. It was probably the best thing I ate all night.
The soup of the day was like a chick pea curry inspired soup which was good and had good flavor. I would’ve liked a whole bowl for sure.
Then the pizza….oh the pizza….shoot….not good. Great sounding list of ingredients…just really plain crust and flavor lacking sauce. I was offered a 2nd slice and said “no thanks”
Beerwise, I started off with the summer ale, which was good, not great, and better than most…then I had a porter to finish things off and was disappointed in the lack of complex flavors that I would have liked to expect in such a strong beer. There was no pale ale on the menu and aside from the porter, everything on tap was seasonal. For a place, who’s hype was built on home brewed beer…I was terriblly disappointed in the beer selections.
I found myself there again 2 days later…so decided to give Mad Fox a second chance.
This time, we ordered the pork belly and fried green tomato apps along with the 12 item super garden salad or something (with tuna added on). I ordered the brisket sandwich with a side caesar salad.
The fried green tomatoes were horrible. They had so much breading on them, they looked like fried zucchinis and it killed any of the flavor of the tomato. They were served with some tomato chutney mess that actually tasted pretty good, but I really think it needs some kind of a creamy sauce to go along with all that damn breading.
The pork belly came out looking flimsy, not crisp, the texture looked strange, but the colors looked good. I had no idea what the dish would taste like and despite the weird looking texture….tasted good. Probably the best tasting thing I have had there to date.
The super salad she ordered was hosed down with a super soaker of dressing and was a nasty soaky mess and if it was in fact all local ingredients…I would love to know where the local kalamata olives are grown and get my own.
I got the brisket sandwich and porter BBQ sauce. It was good and served on a nice bread and I loved the porter BBQ sauce. It fit the bun well and I would definitely order it again….but there is WAY better brisket places to go. I got a super soaked caesar salad instead of fries due to a misunderstanding between me and the waitress. No big deal
Both times I went, the service was great. The bar area was packed at prime happy hour time, but we were able to secure a full service bar table as a group was just leaving. Mike was our waiter and was always there to replenish the drinks and order my next course. The 2nd time was on a Monday night…not nearly as crowded…This time got great full service at a table over looking Broad Street. A sweet and friendly waitress was there and was very attentive.
Let me recap
tuna tartare: good
mussels: bad
pretzels: good
pizza: bad
grilled cheese: bad
soup: good
fried green tomatoes: bad (really bad)
pork belly: good
super salad: bad
brisket: good
That’s a 50% success rate on food…..but 100% success rate the way it sounds on the extremely well written menu. If it all only tasted as good as it sounded.
It will be a hard sell for me to ever want to eat anything there again. What a shameful disappointment.